Turning Red: Growing Up Between Freedom and Belonging

Posted by:

|

On:

|

There is something wonderfully normal about Pixar’s Turning Red, which is a strange thing to say about a movie where a thirteen-year-old girl turns into a giant red panda.

Beneath the chaos, fur, and embarrassment, the movie is really about one of the most ordinary and complicated tasks of adolescence: figuring out who you are while still belonging to the people who raised you.

Mei is not trying to sort out just one identity. She is navigating several at once: how she sees herself, how her friends see her, how her family defines her, and how her cultural traditions shape who she is expected to become.

That tension is what made the movie so interesting to me.

Adolescence is already a complicated period of development. You are beginning to understand yourself as an individual, but you are still deeply embedded in your family system. You are expected to become more responsible and mature, while at the same time being given very limited autonomy.

In other words: be grown, but not too grown.

That contradiction alone creates an enormous amount of conflict.

For Mei, puberty and adolescence also collide with something much larger. The red panda is not simply a bizarre biological change. It is connected to her family history and cultural inheritance. She has to figure out what this transformation means to her personally while also navigating what it means to her mother and the generations of women who came before her.

That is where Turning Red becomes more than a puberty metaphor.

Identity is not formed in isolation. We develop inside overlapping cultures. There is the culture of our family, the culture of our friends, our religious or community traditions, and the larger society around us. Sometimes those cultures work together. Sometimes they collide.

Mei is trying to belong to all of them while simultaneously becoming herself.

Her mother, Ming, has her own complicated relationship with the panda and has learned that controlling or suppressing it is the appropriate response. Mei is therefore not just navigating her own emotions. She is also inheriting a family response to those emotions.

That makes their conflict particularly compelling. Mei is not simply rebelling against her mother. She is beginning the developmental work of separating from her parents while still loving and needing them.

That process is difficult in almost every family.

Different cultures mark adolescence and adulthood in very different ways. Religious ceremonies, cultural rites of passage, debutante traditions, and countless other practices recognize that there is something significant about this transition. Even without a formal ritual, adolescence carries enormous social weight.

We tell young people that they are becoming adults.

Then we remind them that they are still children.

We expect independence, responsibility, emotional regulation, academic success, social competence, and good judgment, often before giving them much actual control over their lives.

It is no wonder adolescence can feel enormous.

That is what makes the giant panda such an effective metaphor. Mei’s transformation is completely impossible, yet emotionally it feels strangely accurate. Adolescence can feel exactly that dramatic. Your body changes. Your emotions change. Your relationships change. Other people suddenly respond to you differently, and meanwhile you are still trying to figure out who you are.

From both a mental-health and child-development perspective, I thought Turning Red handled that tension remarkably well.

The movie is rooted in Mei’s particular family and cultural experience, and those details matter. At the same time, the developmental questions underneath her story are widely recognizable.

How do you become independent without losing your connection to your family?

How do you honor where you came from without allowing tradition to determine every part of who you become?

How do you belong to a community while still becoming an individual?

And perhaps most importantly, what do you do with the parts of yourself that other people would prefer you suppress?

Ultimately, Turning Red does not suggest that growing up means rejecting family, culture, or tradition. Nor does it suggest that maturity requires eliminating every messy or inconvenient part of ourselves.

Instead, Mei begins learning how to live with all of those pieces at once.

She can love her family without becoming an exact copy of them.

She can carry her culture without surrendering her individuality.

She can grow up without completely erasing the child she was.

For a movie about a giant red panda barreling through Toronto, that is a surprisingly nuanced portrayal of adolescence.

Rating: 5/5 Red Pandas 🐼

Turning Red (2022). © 2022 Disney/Pixar. All Rights Reserved. Official promotional image courtesy of Disney+ Press.

Editorial note: This is an independent review. The Read Rover is not affiliated with or endorsed by Disney or Pixar.

Where to Watch: Turning Red is available on Disney+.
Accessibility: Disney+ currently lists Audio Description and Subtitles/Closed Caption

Posted by

in

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *